KPDS 2005 Kasım (Cloze Test)

[MehmetMamger]

In the later part of the Middle Ages, cities created asylums to cope with the mentally ill. These asylums were simply prisons; the inmates were kept on chains in dark, filthy cells and were treated more as animals than as human beings. It (17) ---- until 1792, when Philippe Pinel was placed in charge of an asylum in Paris, that some improvements were made. As an experiment, Pinel removed the chains that restrained the inmates. Much to the amazement of skeptics, who thought Pinel was mad to unchain such "animals", the experiment was a success. When placed in clean, sunny rooms, and treated kindly, many people who for years had been considered hopelessly insane improved enough to leave the asylum.

17.
A) has not been
B) had not been
C) was not
D) would not be
E) would not have been

Belli ki cevap C. Neden B olamıyor? Sağlam bir açıklama istiyorum.

PS: Sağlam olmasa da olur.

[Fatih Hoca]

In the later part of the Middle Ages, cities created asylums to cope with the mentally ill. These asylums were simply prisons; the inmates were kept on chains in dark, filthy cells and were treated more as animals than as human beings. It (17) ---- until 1792, when Philippe Pinel was placed in charge of an asylum in Paris, that some improvements were made. As an experiment, Pinel removed the chains that restrained the inmates. Much to the amazement of skeptics, who thought Pinel was mad to unchain such "animals", the experiment was a success. When placed in clean, sunny rooms, and treated kindly, many people who for years had been considered hopelessly insane improved enough to leave the asylum.

17.
A) has not been
B) had not been
C) was not
D) would not be
E) would not have been

Belli ki cevap C. Neden B olamıyor? Sağlam bir açıklama istiyorum.

PS: Sağlam olmasa da olur.

It wasn't until .......................that yapısında wasn't yerine hadn't been kullnıldığına hiç şahit olmadım.

[MehmetMamger]

It wasn't until .......................that yapısında wasn't yerine hadn't been kullnıldığına hiç şahit olmadım.

Ben de şahit olmadım ama kişisel tecrübe dışında bir açıklama beklemekteyim. Bu arada TIK.

[Fatih Hoca]

Ben de şahit olmadım ama kişisel tecrübe dışında bir açıklama beklemekteyim. Bu arada TIK.

O TIK ların toplam sayısı 162 . Bunların da yarısı THAT içermeyen cümleler.Kişisel tecrübeler başlangıç itibarıyla bir kaynağa dayalı gelişir ve boy atarlar. Tek sorun bu kaynağın ne olduğunu hatırlayabilmek

Bu arada TIK

[themg]

Much of olmamasının nedeni nedir acaba ? "Much to" olması hangi durumlarda oluyor

Cevabınız için şimdiden teşekkür ederim.

[themg]

edit:mükerrer

[chopperman]

Hocam sanırım iki eylem aynı anda yapıldığı için past perfect olmaz.
........ "when Philippe Pinel was placed in charge of an asylum in Paris"

[TheBest90]

kesin zaman var o yüzden simple olmalı ,until 1792