24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.
A) Compared with those of the iron age, stone age tools were very primitive
B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries
C) The "bronze age" is a term used in prehistoric archaeology
D) The chemical processes involved in the smelting of ones were not as complicated
E) subsequently the knowledge of metalworking must have spread among the less advanced communities around

2001 Mayıs KPDS

A derdim hocam, hem anlam hem de tense uyumu...

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.

B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries

B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries derdim . ama tense uyumunda şüphelerim var.

A derdim hocam, hem anlam hem de tense uyumu...

katılıyorum hocam "A" (mı? :))

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.

B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries

Haklısınız outside... görmemişim:)

Bence B şıkkı...

katılıyorum hocam "A" (mı? :))

ama bi dakkaa :eek:

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.

B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries

evet "not found in all countries" atlamışım..ama ya tense uyumu :confused:

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.
A) Compared with those of the iron age, stone age tools were very primitive
B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries
C) The "bronze age" is a term used in prehistoric archaeology
D) The chemical processes involved in the smelting of ones were not as complicated
E) subsequently the knowledge of metalworking must have spread among the less advanced communities around

2001 Mayıs KPDS


ore
noun [C or U]
rock or soil from which metal can be obtained:
iron/copper ore

bana pek tatmin edici gelmedi.

cevap ne olarak verilmiş hocam öğrenebilirmiyim?

Anlamca B şıkkı uygun geliyor.

Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.





.

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.
A) Compared with those of the iron age, stone age tools were very primitive
B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries
C) The "bronze age" is a term used in prehistoric archaeology
D) The chemical processes involved in the smelting of ones were not as complicated
E) subsequently the knowledge of metalworking must have spread among the less advanced communities around

2001 Mayıs KPDS


Bu iki cümle arasında zaman uyumu aramak gerekir mi? Birinci cümlede yani B şıkkındaki cümlede genelleme yapmış. Sonra olayı anlatmış...

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.
A) Compared with those of the iron age, stone age tools were very primitive
B) Many ones (ores), such as copper and tin are not found in all countries
C) The "bronze age" is a term used in prehistoric archaeology
D) The chemical processes involved in the smelting of ones were not as complicated
E) subsequently the knowledge of metalworking must have spread among the less advanced communities around

2001 Mayıs KPDS


B) Many ores, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.


Explanation : It is a fact that in our present day, many ores, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries. Considering this reality, one can assume that the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.In other words :

Many ores, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries, so the introduction of metalworking made (must have made) trade with the outside world inevitable.

24. ----, so the introduction of metalworking made trade with the outside world inevitable.
A) Compared with those of the iron age, stone age tools were very primitive
B) Many ones, such as copper and tin are not found in all countries
C) The "bronze age" is a term used in prehistoric archaeology
D) The chemical processes involved in the smelting of ones were not as complicated
E) subsequently the knowledge of metalworking must have spread among the less advanced communities around

2001 Mayıs KPDS

Çokça umursadığım bir ÖSYM sorusu. "Sebep önce, sonuç sonra gerçekleşir ve tenseler de buna göre olmalıdır" ezberini bozuyor. Zira genel bir sebep cümlesi (present tense), geçmişte de aynı gerekçe var olacağından, geçmişteki bir sonuçla (past tense) birleşebilir.

İnsanlar acımasızdırlar, işte o yüzden binlerce savaşta milyonlarca cana kıydılar. (present, past birlikteliği) [present sebep, past sonuç]

Oksijensiz yaşayamayız, dolayısıyla yaşam ilk ortaya ancak gerekli atmosfer koşulları oluşunca ortaya çıkabildi. [present sebep, past sonuç]

Bakır ve teneke gibi çoğu metal her ülkede bulunmaz, işte bundan dolayı metal eşylar yapımı dış dünya ile ticareti kaçınılmaz kılmıştı. [present sebep, past sonuç]

PS: Metindeki "the outside" ancak "not found in all countries" ile anlamlandırılabiliyor. Bu da aslında soruyu doğru çözebilmek için yeterliydi.

Sebep-sonuç ilişkilerinde nadir sorgulanan bir kısım olduğu için paylaşmak istedim. OSYM tarihinde yanılmıyorsam, sebep cümelesi genel-geçerliliğe sahip olduğu için simple present tense ile yapılmış 1-2 soru daha var bu şekilde. Ayrıntılı açıklamalar için hocalarıma teşekkürler :)