Tam Sürüm Bilgini Göster : Dilemma 4. What would you do?


Spartakus
12th August 2007, 13:44
A Poisonous Cup of Coffee, with Jane and Debbie added for the sake of gender equality.

Tom[/Jane], hating his[/her] wife[/husband] and wanting her[/him] dead, puts poison in her[/his] coffee, thereby killing her[/him]. Joe[/Debbie] also hates his[/her] wife[/husband] and would like her[/him] dead. One day, Joe's[/Debbie's] wife[/husband] accidentally puts poison in her[/his] coffee, thinking it's cream. Joe[/Debbie] has the antidote, but he[/she] does not give it to her[/him]. Knowing that he[/she] is the only one who can save her[/him], he[/she] lets her[/him] die. Is Joe's[/Debbie's] failure to act as bad as Tom's[/Jane's] action?

Saadet Çadır
12th August 2007, 21:53
In that way or the other, the result is she is dead and although he could have changed this tragic end he didn t interfere in as this was what he had wanted, so ,of course he is the one to put the blame on :))

DarkMessiah
12th August 2007, 22:07
If i was to sentence the first one to 20 years, i would sentence the second one to the half of it cause the second one's actor did not planned to murder.

gül_23
12th August 2007, 22:15
Although the first one poisoned his(her) wife(husband) the second one did it accidentally but ı think they both share the same sin 'cause despite this two different case they both killed their wife(husband) intentionally.

Carmenta
12th August 2007, 23:28
I am confused :ices_tot::confused::eek: